Thousands of gifted students across the country are turning to homeschooling as a viable alternative to the traditional classroom.
By Annie Connolly-Sporing and Jonathan A. Plucker, March 2024
Sophie, 12, and Leah, 8, are gifted learners who have been homeschooled by their mother for the past five years. While Leah has been homeschooled since the start of her formal education in PreK, Sophie began her educational journey in a traditional classroom setting. Sophie attended a small private school from PreK until February of second grade. Because of her high academic aptitude, she was placed into the accelerated group, but that level of differentiation was not enough to meet her academic needs. Her interests in literature and history led her to the library, where she wanted to read non-fiction texts about historical events such as World War II, but the library did not allow her to read those works despite her elevated Lexile level and parental consent. After years of asking the school for more, being met with “we’ve done all we can,” watching Sophie develop stress-induced asthma, and being asked by their daughter to try something different, Sophie’s parents decided to homeschool her and her sister. Five years later, Sophie loves her homeschool community, has read multiple Newbery Award-winning books, serves as a National Beta Club vice president, and is learning Latin. Her family’s only regret: not making the change earlier.
Current estimates suggest that there are between 50,000 and 140,000 students across the country in the same position as Sophie. In light of recent data indicating a 50% increase in homeschooling since the 2017-2018 school year, this figure is likely an underestimate. These students, with their high academic potential and status as gifted learners, have not had their unique needs met in the standard American classroom, leaving them wanting more. Like Sophie and her family, these students are turning to homeschooling as a viable alternative to the traditional classroom.
Despite the fact that there may be 100,000 advanced students learning primarily in homeschool settings, the research regarding the cross-section of homeschooling and giftedness is limited. Much of the current research relies on anecdotal evidence from a select population of families, often garnered from blog posts and other web pages. The lack of high-quality research has perpetuated the obscurity surrounding homeschooling gifted learners.
One common trend that emerges in the minimal literature on this topic is that parents of gifted learners turn to homeschooling after multiple fruitless attempts to work with the school to meet their children’s needs. In many cases, this derives from a lack of understanding and training surrounding educating advanced students. Only 10 states have funded mandates for gifted education, and 35 states have no requirement for general education teachers to be trained in the best practices of gifted education. As a result, gifted students in the general classroom often do not have their needs met in terms of pace, academic level, and rigor. After what, in some cases, can be years of advocating for change for their student, families begin to look for other options, be it a different learning environment or removal of the learning environment altogether.
Choosing to homeschool a gifted child mitigates the issue of not having their needs met by enabling the caregiver to curate a program specific to their child’s needs and interests. For this reason, the academic programming for a homeschooled gifted learner can look very different from student to student. Although some families choose to use a premade curriculum and embellish where needed, other families curate an entirely unique academic path using a combination of enrollment in community college courses, online auditing of classes from accredited universities, private tutoring, student-led academic exploration, and more. No matter the route taken, this individualized programming provides the gifted student with the differentiated learning experience they lack in the general classroom.
However, this specialized programming can be very expensive, and many homeschoolers of gifted learners have had to make serious sacrifices, not only financially but in time and careers, to give this experience to their learners. Some estimates suggest that the average cost of homeschooling ranges from $700-1,800 per year, while others suggest the value is closer to $2,500, and the use of services such as private tutors or teachers can push this cost into the tens of thousands of dollars. That cost does not account for the time and energy caregivers expend sifting through resources and reviewing programming, nor for the sacrifice that a parent often makes in giving up their profession and related income. With all these factors considered, homeschooling is not a decision that families take lightly. Many families enter this education model with eyes open to the challenges they are likely to encounter.
As stated previously, the research regarding this population of homeschooled students is limited. To truly understand the scope, purpose, and programming of gifted homeschooling, more research should be conducted to parse out trends in the population. Namely, research should focus on determining how many gifted students are currently being homeschooled in the United States, why those families choose to homeschool their children, how those students are performing academically compared to their non-homeschooled gifted peers, and what methods families are using to homeschool those children.
By unraveling the stories of homeschooled gifted learners, it becomes clear that their journeys are as diverse as the students themselves. Conducting research on this unique group of learners may provide insight into the nuances of personalized education, highlighting its use in educating some of the nation’s brightest learners.
Citations
Gill, A. (2024, January 17). What is the cost of homeschooling: A comprehensive guide. SplashLearn Blog – Educational Resources for Parents, Teachers & Kids. https://www.splashlearn.com/blog/cost-of-homeschooling/
Hazen, T. (2023, May 24). 2024 Homeschooling Costs – Programs & Tax Credits. Tutors. https://tutors.com/costs/homeschooling-cost
Jamison, P., Merkler, L., Gordy, P., Ence Morse, C., & Alcantara, C. (2023, October 31). Home schooling’s rise from fringe to fastest-growing form of education. Washington Post. Retrieved January 21, 2024, from https://www.washingtonpost.com/education/interactive/2023/homeschooling-growth-data-by-district/
Rinn, A. N., Mun, R. U., & Hodges, J. (2022). 2020-2021 State of the states in gifted education. National Association for Gifted Children and the Council of State Directors of Programs for the Gifted.
Jolly, J. L., & Matthews, M. S. (2017). The chronicles of homeschooling gifted learners. Journal of School Choice, 12(1), 123–145. https://doi.org/10.1080/15582159.2017.1354644
Jolly, J. L., Matthews, M. S., & Nester, J. (2012). Homeschooling the gifted. Gifted Child Quarterly, 57(2), 121–134. https://doi.org/10.1177/0016986212469999
Kearney, K. (1984). At home in Maine: Gifted children and homeschooling. G/C/T, 7(3), 15–19. https://doi.org/10.1177/107621758400700305
